"Top 5 Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara For 2020: Essential Guide "

Top 5 Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara For 2020: Essential Guide

In the past decade, a lot of brands have decided to end terrible animal treatment and go cruelty free, and some of them have put out many amazing and beloved makeup items, including waterproof mascaras. If you’re about to go green and renovate your makeup bag, yet you don’t know where to start, we have created a list of the best cruelty free waterproof mascara for you to choose from. 

A quick comparison: 5 best cruelty free waterproof mascara

Keep reading! Here’s a comparison of the top 5:


Detail Review Of Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara


Let’s dive into these products to find out which Cruelty-Free Waterproof Mascara best!
Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara

It’s nice to see that mascara can live up to its legendary non-waterproof counterpart. The brush is still hourglass-shaped, so giving your lashes curls and volume in one application is no problem. It separates, lifts and lengthens your lashes just as easily and fantastically as the other one.

Despite the waterproof formula, you can trust this one not to dry out your lashes and still give you that dramatic and lavish look just like you’re wearing fake lashes. This one can also hold your curls steadily all day long. 

It’s also on the list of the best cruelty free waterproof mascara from many clients.

  • Thing we liked
  • Things we didn't like
  • Doesn’t condition lashes
  • A bit expensive
Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara

This drugstore mascara is famous for its intense volumizing effect. Your lashes will be three times thicker after applying, and that is not to mention the lifting that it can do. Say goodbye to those thin and straight eyelashes. 

This fiber brush is not too thick so it will take some more time to put this mascara on, but it can easily separate those clumps and flakes. Your lashes will look breathtaking all day too, even in the areas of high humidity or if you’re prone to lots of sweat.

The formula is so strong that it can be a bit challenging to remove this mascara.

  • Thing we liked
  • Things we didn't like
  • Slim brush
  • Hard to remove
Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara

The thing I love about this mascara is that it’s versatile. Since it’s buildable, if you want to go light and natural, you can just apply once or twice, and you can do several layers for a more intense look. It does an amazing job lengthening and lifting your eyelashes as well.

This mascara has very natural ingredients, mainly vitamin-based and non-toxic, so it can condition your lashes and groom them over time. It can still resist all the sweat and damp air while locking your curls throughout the day.

Just like the name suggests, it also comes with a blue color. However, it can get a bit dry at the end of the day.

  • Thing we liked
  • Things we didn't like
  • Can get quite dry
Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara

This is perfect for you if you want a bold black eye makeup look. The color is really intense so it ensures the pitch-black color even if your lashes have a lighter or blonde shade. Although it doesn’t do much lengthening, it can still create a fuller and thicker look to your eyes since it adds great volume to them.

You can totally avoid those flakes and smudges at the end of the day and it’s extremely water-resistant. The hypoallergenic formula is also very suitable for sensitive eyes.

  • Thing we liked
  • Things we didn't like
  • Not lengthening
  • Hard to remove
Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara

This particular mascara uses a tubing technology that allows the mascara to form tubes around your eyelashes and cling onto them for great volume. It’s certainly buildable, so the more you apply, the thicker the tubes get and the fuller your eyes look. This technology makes the mascara more resistant to impacts, including water.

The large brush helps add maximum volume as well. This mascara is more natural-looking, and although it’s a bit drier than others, you can go back and build up the mascara throughout the day. It’s also smudge-proof.

Thanks to the tubing, washing this off is incredibly easy, you just need water and constant but gentle rubbing on the lashes.

  • Thing we liked
  • Things we didn't like
  • Dry
  • Expensive

How to identify cruelty-free makeup

Although going cruelty-free is optional, many makeup brands have recently claimed to have stopped animal testing in response to the increasing public pressure, introducing the best cruelty-free waterproof mascara. Yet, it may not be that easy to differentiate what is truly an ethical movement and what is just a promoting ruse.

The best way to ensure you’re spending your money in the right place is to check for cruelty-free logos.

Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara

Leaping Bunny certifications

The Leaping Bunny Program was established by several animal protection groups in the 1990s in response to the animal-friendly trends going on in the makeup world. Their logo is now internationally recognized and issued for use by cosmetics and household brands that meet their given criteria against animal testing. 

The Leaping Bunny is by far the most selective in comparison with other certifications. They don’t just require written documents and agreements from the brands, but they also do a full investigation from the suppliers to the manufacturers with annual renewal policies. 

Their list of cruelty-free brands has over 600 names now, so it’s easy to choose a suitable brand. You can go to their website to check out their list and download the Compassionate Shopping Guide for better insight into the cruelty-free market.

Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara

Why you should own waterproof mascara

Have you ever attended an outdoor event all day long and kept worrying about your makeup? Maybe your mascara started to smudge or fade in the middle of the day. This is where waterproof mascara comes in handy. Thanks to the stronger formula, it can hold up your curls in perfect position all day long and not give you those raccoon-like eyes.

It’s water-resistant, so it’ll do just fine if it’s the wedding season or a barbecue party. Maybe you just want to be able to go running outside or heading to the gym and still want to look good. The formula can fight humidity as well, so a day on the beach should also be a piece of cake. Waterproof mascara is just the ideal makeup item on your back in hot summer days.

Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Mascara

However, I don’t recommend you use waterproof mascara on a daily basis, because it prevents water from reaching your lashes so continual use would probably make your eyes dry and brittle. The strong formula isn’t easy to wash off either. If not done properly, you can take out a few lashes or leave some of the mascara behind, and it will create a zone of bacteria and irritate your eyes in the long run.

To remove without damaging your lashes, you should use waterproof makeup removers, which are usually oil-based. If you don’t want to spend more bucks, use coconut or olive oil and the best cruelty-free waterproof mascara still works wonderfully. Be gentle while rubbing the mascara off, don’t violently chafe or tug your lashes. I suggest you add some lash serum or condition in your skincare routine on those days as well.

Check this out for some tips on how to remove waterproof mascara:

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, based on the top reviews of the options out there now, I would say the best one is the Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara. It just does the best job holding your eyelash curls throughout the day, so if you’re in need of something sweatproof for the gym or a day out on the beach, this is it!

What do you think is the best cruelty free waterproof mascara? 

Let us know in the comments and don’t forget to like and share this article.

Leave a Comment